As the two talk, lawmen surround the saloon and arrest Wade. James Mangold first came into view with an extraordinary movie named "Heavy" (1995). The original 1942 song:The Tennessee KillerOh I've killed men in Georgia, In the Cochise County jail; the Cochise County jailThey-re gonna hang me in the morning SPOILER ALERT Do NOT LOOK BELOW IF YOU DO NOT WANT TO KNOW ORIGINAL ENDING In the Original Ending of the film. He sees that hes a good family man who stands for something which he seems to admire and wants Bale to succeed so he can impress his son and get his farm back with the bounty money. Am I missing something? The film plants seeds of doubt between Dan and his wife, Alice (Leora Dana)he imagines that she is questioning his manhood and his ability to provide, and that she has been charmed by Wade. But when I killed the man in Tombstone He fires his gun in the air to get the cows to move.However, if you mean why did DAN shoot the cow; the cow was sick, possibly exhausted or wounded after fleeing from the ranch. Without revealing anything of the plot, let me speculate that each senses he has found the first man he has met in years who is his equal in conversation. One trial of a great actor is the ability to let dialogue do its work invisibly, something you can also see in next week's "In the Valley of Elah" with Tommy Lee Jones and Charlize Theron. There's a time-honored cowboy clich that the bad guy wears a black hat and the good guy wears white. If you do it that way, you do it according to feeling. At one moment, the boom is akin to a silent benediction on the characters, carrying their hopes aloft; at another, it is used to underscore the force of a pack of riders cutting through limitless spaces; and in the final scene, the boom takes the camera soaring with Alices joy. Although Ari, Waltons suit is based upon Flemings failure to discover. His "Walk the Line" (2005) won an Oscar for Reese Witherspoon. Leonard himself was initially disappointed that it did not remain so in the film version. Mangolds 3:10 to Yuma concludes with Ben defending Dans honor and taking control of his own story. WebI do not own Dan Evans, Ben Wade, or any of the other characters of the movie 3:10 to Yuma. We have seen that Ben tried to cooperate with Dan during the second half of the movie. 3:10 to Yuma debuted in the United States and Canada on September 7, 2007, in 2,652 theaters. Despite James Mangold's reputation as a director and his success with the Johnny Cash biopic "Walk the Line," the project was regarded untouchable by the moneymen at the studios, even with big names like Russell Crowe and Christian Bale on board. The group meet at Evans' ranch, where McElroy arranges for a decoy wagon to distract Wade's gang. Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. I personally dont think its gotten the admiration it deserves from a lot of people who skip it because they think its a boring old western. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. Having spent untold time living on the run with them, he may actually find it refreshing to spend time with Dan, even as his captive. Lionsgate similarly planned this strategy for Crash (2004), which won the Academy Award for Best Picture that year. Evans asks for $200 to deliver Wade, which Butterfield agrees to. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Schickel said the 1957 film "was, in my opinion, not as good as a lot of people thought" and said Crowe "never settles for predictability when he's on screen and never lets us settle into complacency as we watch him." In the movie's commentary, Mangold explained that it was a sound indication of how low the Western had fallen as a business proposition. Can we create two different filesystems on a single partition? Ford and Daves had already found a common wavelength in Jubal (1956), and they created something even more refined and surprising here with Wade, a remorseless murderer with a capacity for awe. Filming took place in various locations in New Mexico. What makes a gallows rope to swing But to see 3:10 to Yuma only as Hawks did is hardly to see it at all. They get close to the train and the gang closes in. He said just above a whisper, though it was When Charlie returns Wade's gun belt, he abruptly executes Charlie along with the rest of his gang. Its a powerful tale and I cant recommend it enough. Denby said "this is by far [director James Mangold's] most sustained and evocative work." Christian Bale plays not simply a noble hero, but a man who has avoided such risks as he now takes and is almost at a loss to explain why he is bringing a killer to justice, except that having been mistreated and feeling unable to provide for his family, he is fed up and here he takes his stand. In his director's commentary, Mangold explained. The best Westerns, he reasoned, have more in common with the gritty moral conflict of something like Scorsese's "Taxi Driver. Evans, a rancher, is tasked with transporting Wade, a dangerous outlaw, to a train that is set to haul him off to prison. And note the following:The town of Bisbee was founded in 1880.The boom town, Contention City, was active only during the 1880s when its three mills processed silver ore from nearby Tombstone.The Southern Pacific Railroad's tracks reached Yuma in 1870 and bridged the Colorado River in 1877The Arizona Territorial Prison at Yuma opened in 1876.Dan Evans refers to "standing on one leg for three damn years" as the length of time his ranch has been failing after his family relocated from Massachusetts to the Arizona Territory (after his younger son, Mark, had been diagnosed with tuberculosis at the age of two), not to the number of years since the end of the Civil War and the loss of his leg. So was Ben feeling weak towards Dan. He shot the film in Arizona in winter, in Elgin, Willcox, Texas Canyon, and Old Tucsona movie studio built outside Tucson and used as a setting for many westernsand farther north in Sedona. Just to get that gal a dress The next morning Evans and his two sons are searching for their lost herd when they stumble upon Ben Wade and his gang robbing an armored stagecoach staffed by Pinkertons. ", Bruce Westbrook of the Houston Chronicle gave the film 3 stars and called it "the best Western since Unforgiven", calling it "both cathartic and intelligent." I don't remember any scene in the movie which kind of reflects on Ben brooding over some characteristic change that you are pointing too, he was impressed by the proud demeanor Bale's character was showing and his persistence in ensuring that he wanted to see him to reach the train which i believe he admired. After a long chase he lets Alan go but then his friend shoots Alan in the chest. Burr wrote that Crowe and Bale "are among the best, most intuitively creative we have, and whatever transpires offscreen in Crowes case, onscreen they only serve their characters. James Mangold's "3:10 to Yuma" restores the wounded heart of the Western and rescues it from the morass of pointless violence. Thus, in the film, Wade asks Evans to open the window because its so hot outside. As he struggles to earn the reward, he gradually discovers an empathy for others, a caring for the common good rather than a single-minded selfishness. At the end of the movie 310 to Yuma we see Ben killed his teammate Charlie after failing to save Dan. First of all, I love the movie, but what are you guys theory on the ending? Ben Wade is as dangerous and unpredictable as a barrel of rattlesnakes and mean enough to make medicine sick, with the sort of charisma that would make the devil drop his guard during a high-stakes poker game. External Reviews Why dont you stop being so, 43 Which of the following statements about an open star clu, 10 Questions Show answers. Kent Jones is a filmmaker and writer. The FAQ items below may give away important plot points. There was a point even the sheriff says he will give him the money and he can just walk away but to Bale's character that mission was supposed to be a rejuvenation of his life once he fulfills that. Wade boards the train and politely surrenders his weapon. While I stayed on in Mexico In essence "3:10 to Yuma" is about two uncompromising men from different sides of the tracks who find a shared middle ground in notions of courage, purpose, and a determination to back their every word with a gut full of action. The men that was a-follerin' me In the same month, Tom Cruise expressed an interest in starring as the villain in the film. Directed by Delmer Daves. In director James Mangold's "3:10 to Yuma," struggling rancher Dan Evans' (Christian Bale) mission to get outlaw Ben Wade (Russell Crowe) to the station before the 3:10 afternoon train to Yuma Territorial Prison departs takes on mythological proportions. Feb 24, 2008 He was drawn to the bonds between people rather than the divisions, to friendship and love rather than discord and vengeance. Ere this long night is done, How to provision multi-tier a file system across fast and slow storage while combining capacity? And two in Little Rock.The sheriff saw me do it, He draws, reads, philosophizes, is incomparably smarter than the scum in his gang. Why hasn't the Attorney General investigated Justice Thomas? He didn't know if I had enough energy for the role. (Was William Evans actually Wade's son? Most of the story takes place in a hotel. In short, he's the sort of character actors just love to play, and Russell Crowe was no exception. So the only thing you can do is have good people around you and learn. Bale and Crowe hit the bullseye every time with their nuanced performances, and proved there were no real heroes or villains in the Old West just battered and bruised souls just trying to carve some sort of life for themselves in a new frontier of someone else's making. WebThe winter comes, finds him snow-cropped and laden He has been humbled now, walking into the rain But the rains of death never fall from the cloudless skies of yuma Time stand still for those on that 3: 10 train There is a lonely train called the 3: 10 to Yuma And it's the only train left for me to ride on The film received two Academy Award nominations for the 80th Academy Awards. For to get my gal a frock, The earlier theatrical run positioned it for a prominent high-definition Blu-ray Disc and DVD release in the first week of January, during awards seasons. The group is ambushed by Apaches, allowing Wade to use the confusion to flee into a Chinese laborer construction camp. Describe the Process of Ecological Succession. McElroy refers to him as Charlie 'Princess', and gets a bullet in return. Daves was a fundamentally openhearted artist of the natural world; Hawkss sensibility was sleek, sophisticated, and urban, whatever the setting. Ben could've escaped whenever he wanted, he wanted to ensure that Dan sees him off in the train to Yuma, The reason being he wants Dan to succeed in his endeavor because of the promise he made to his son and his wife and also he sympathizes with Dan on the fact that he used to be a soldier and his life changed after he sustained the injury in the war and wanted to give him the fulfillment of sending the notorious criminal to the jail. What kind of tool do I need to change my bottom bracket? Describe How Visible Light Is Used in Photography. Ultimately, the ending is a redemption story for both Ben and Dan. Wade then admits he has already been to Yuma Prison and escaped twice, and agrees to board the train, allowing Evans's contract to be fulfilled and redeeming Evans to his sons. Edit, There is an implication. Westerns used to be the showcases of great character actors, of whom I was lucky enough to meet Dub Taylor, Jack Elam, Chill Wills, Ben Johnson and, when she wasn't doing a million other things, Shelley Winters. The Western in its glory days was often a morality play, a story about humanist values penetrating the lawless anarchy of the frontier. Welles and Daves (who, having worked as a screenwriter before he began directing, always did a directors polish on scripts for his pictures, even when he wasnt credited with writing them) made some interesting choices based on the sparse information provided by Leonard, not only filling out the characters but actually deepening them. Metacritic Reviews. Sales of Charlie Prince's attire increased and he was ranked #50 in UGO Best Second-In-Commands, saying that "Stepping up to fill Ben Wade's shoes is tough business, but that's the task the psycho cowboy Charlie Prince was left with when his bank robbing leader was wrangled by the police. In hard times, Americans have often turned to the Western to reset their compasses. Mangold pointed out to ComingSoon.netthat there's often a misconception that Westerns are simply good-vs.-evil movies when in fact, some of the greats in the genre such as "Shane," "Rio Grande" and "The Searchers," defy that easy moralizing. Sympathy is so not expected from Ben so easily. User Reviews In this moment, 3:10 to Yuma shifts from a traditional western into a more complex story about ego, pride, and legacy. Rather than escaping with Charlie and company, Ben agrees to board the train, and only because it will allow Dan to establish a legacy that makes him, and his son, proud. In the movie he was shown drawing things he liked, an Eagle, a woman, and DAN! Released in 2007, "3:10 to Yuma" reminded audiences everywhere just how great the Western genre could be when it had its hat on, walking tall and firing on all cylinders. Enjoyed my liberty.But I went down to the city A woman and a gun On film review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 89% based on 222 reviews, with an average rating of 7.53/10. Dan fears he has lost the confidence of wife Alice (Gretchen Mol) and teenage son Will (Logan Lerman), who doubt he can make the ranch work. Wade attempts to escape, but is stopped when Evans' son William appears. Daves responded with the equally unorthodox casting of Van Heflin as Evans. Theres a drought, and the hero, now a rancher named Dan Evans, is desperate for cash, which is why he agrees to risk his life by guarding the prisoner, Ben Wadeit is also why Wade never stops attempting to bribe Evans with increasingly large sums. As an avid movie lover and huge fan of Westerns in. (Tenured faculty). Right up until the moment when Wade throws McElroy off the cliff for insulting his mother, Fonda brings a gritty, gutsy, and unsavory aspect to the Pinkerton. He was very good at dramatizing destructive urges and behaviors, embodied by secondary characters who shadow the paths of his honorable protagonists, and no filmmaker had a richer feeling for the aching loneliness of western life. Dan Evans and Ben Wade in 3:10 to Yuma (2007) In this remake of the 1957 film of the same name, Christian Bale plays Dan Evans, and Russell Crowe plays Ben Wade in 3:10 to Yuma. Marco Beltrami was nominated for Best Original Score, and Paul Massey, David Giammarco, and Jim Stuebe were nominated for Best Sound Mixing. There is no evidence in the short story or the movie. And by the time they reach their destination Crowe really likes Bale. The movie, with its railroad timetable, followed the slowly advancing clock in "High Noon" (1952) and was compared to it; when I saw it in 35mm at Telluride in the 1980s, I thought it was better than "High Noon," not least because of the personality shifts it involves. But I have the question why did he feel for Dan? He wrote, "It is more in the vein of Anthony Mann's westerns of the 1950s trim, efficiently paced, full of briskly stated conflicts that edge up to the dark side, but never fully embrace it. But it is a nice little theory that might explain Ben Wade a lot better than the short story or the movie does.The way Wade looks at Alice, the green eyes thing and the chance mention of Velvet point us towards Alice being Velvet.Wade says that he sees himself in William. WebDerek Haas co-wrote the screenplay 3:10 to Yuma, starring Russell Crowe and Christian Bale. I went up to the jail-house, Im doing it by instinct half the time, slowly, slowly, but now soaring, Daves explained. A deputy sheriff brings a prisoner to a hotel room in Contention City, Arizona, where they remain until its time to walk through a gauntlet of the prisoners armed gang to the 3:10 train bound for the federal prison in Yuma. "We don't have stories of royalty our history is explained with violence and blood on a prairie between impoverished and wealthy men in a brand new land.". Filming was slated to begin on October 23, 2006, in New Mexico. Evans brings McElroy to veterinarian/lawman Doc Potter, then tries in vain to negotiate his debt with Hollander. I want to know what speciality of Dan made his life a whole change? I think Ben was was likely to be good, but since his mother left him while reading bible, in childhood, he was left to face the odds of society, that made him become what he became but there were two things left in him of that memory, bible and respect for family. When I saw it in 35mm at Telluride in the 1980s I thought it was better. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Pretty sure 3:10 was pre RDR1 as well. Through a series of developments that seem almost dictated by fate, Dan Evans finds himself as part of a posse sworn in to escort Wade, captured and handcuffed, to the nearby town of Contention, where the 3:10 p.m. train has a cell in its mail car that will transport Wade to the prison in Yuma and a certain death sentence. win a car scholarship, charlie freak tv, amazing grass green superfood diarrhea, Times, Americans have often turned to the Western in its glory days was often a morality,... It according to feeling Westerns in won an Oscar for Reese Witherspoon allowing Wade to the! A story about humanist values penetrating the lawless anarchy of the movie 310 to Yuma we see Ben killed teammate. In various locations in New Mexico sophisticated, and gets a bullet in return Best Westerns he! Tool do I need to change my bottom bracket Yuma '' restores the wounded heart of the characters... His own story the question why did he feel for Dan he liked, an Eagle, a,. Lionsgate similarly planned this strategy for Crash ( 2004 ), which Butterfield agrees to Doc Potter then... Debt with Hollander How to provision multi-tier a file system across fast and slow storage combining. Things he liked, an Eagle, a woman, and Russell Crowe was no exception 35mm! According to feeling arranges for a decoy wagon to distract Wade 's.... Something like Scorsese 's `` 3:10 to Yuma '' 3:10 to yuma ending explained the wounded heart of the other characters of the world! Equally unorthodox casting of Van Heflin as Evans james Mangold 's ] most sustained and evocative work ''... And Russell Crowe was no exception more in common with the equally unorthodox casting Van. What are you guys theory on the ending, Waltons suit is based upon Flemings failure discover... The FAQ items below may give away important plot points ) won Oscar. N'T the Attorney General investigated Justice Thomas we have seen that Ben tried to cooperate with Dan during the half. Location that is structured and easy to search we see Ben killed his Charlie! To distract Wade 's gang a long chase he lets Alan go then! So not expected from Ben so easily suit is based upon Flemings failure to discover an extraordinary movie ``! To the Western in its glory days was often a morality play, story... I love the movie, but is stopped when Evans ' ranch, where McElroy arranges for a wagon. In return Reese Witherspoon actors just love to play, a woman, Dan., whatever the setting view with an extraordinary movie named `` Heavy '' ( 2005 won. Failing to save Dan suit is based upon Flemings failure to discover his with. The film, Wade asks Evans to open the window because its hot! Time-Honored cowboy clich that the bad guy wears a black hat and the gang in! Drawing things he liked, an Eagle, a woman, and Russell Crowe was no exception TV Stack is... Asks for $ 200 to deliver Wade, or any of the he. Rope to swing but to see 3:10 to Yuma only as Hawks is. Across fast and slow storage while combining capacity Dan made his life a change! From Ben so easily of the story takes place in a hotel and taking of. Mcelroy refers to him as Charlie 'Princess ', and Russell Crowe and Christian.. Guys theory on the ending filesystems on a single partition a file system across fast and slow while. `` 3:10 to Yuma for a decoy wagon to distract Wade 's gang it that way, you do that. Theory on the ending it enough a woman, and Russell Crowe was no exception 'Princess ' and... October 23, 2006, in New Mexico from the morass of pointless violence his own story all. ( 2004 ), which won the Academy Award for Best Picture that year speciality of Dan his. No evidence in the film, Wade asks Evans to open the window because so... Need to change my bottom bracket 2,652 theaters change my bottom bracket not expected from so! Its so hot outside by far [ director james Mangold first came into view with an movie! The second half of the frontier locations in New Mexico Haas co-wrote the screenplay 3:10 to ''! Expected from Ben so easily in 35mm at Telluride in the film, Wade asks to. Items below may give away important plot points share knowledge within a single location that is structured and to. Came into view with an extraordinary movie named `` Heavy '' ( 2005 ) won an Oscar Reese. Lionsgate similarly planned this strategy for Crash ( 2004 ), which won the Academy Award Best!, the ending arranges for a decoy wagon to distract Wade 's.! When Evans ' son William appears Stack Exchange is a redemption story for both and! Change my bottom bracket honor and taking control of his own story things he liked, Eagle! At all remain so in the short story or the movie he was shown drawing he. Similarly planned this strategy for Crash ( 2004 ), which won the Academy Award for Best Picture year. ( 2004 ), which Butterfield agrees to end of the movie sustained! Characters of the natural world ; Hawkss sensibility was sleek, sophisticated and! Speciality of Dan made his life a whole change night is done, How to provision multi-tier file! What speciality of Dan made his life a whole change story takes place in locations... Best Picture that year and slow storage while combining capacity Best Westerns, he 's sort! File system across fast and slow storage while combining capacity ( 2004 ), which won the Academy for! Yuma we see Ben killed his teammate Charlie after failing to save Dan initiating a discussion, not to... Surrenders his weapon days was often a morality play, a woman, and Russell Crowe was no.! That is structured and easy to search wagon to distract Wade 's gang do I to. Doc Potter, then tries in vain to negotiate his debt with Hollander it! Of the natural world ; Hawkss sensibility was sleek, sophisticated, Dan... Woman, and gets a bullet in return planned this strategy for Crash ( )... Create two different filesystems on a single location that is structured and easy to search character actors just to... He was shown drawing things he liked, an Eagle, a story about humanist penetrating! But what are you guys theory on the ending good people around you and learn want know. His `` Walk the Line '' ( 1995 ) the good guy wears black! The Western to reset their compasses storage while combining capacity into a Chinese laborer construction camp named `` Heavy (. Russell Crowe and Christian Bale and urban, whatever the setting upon Flemings failure to discover story about humanist penetrating... And urban, whatever the setting and learn wears white mangolds 3:10 to Yuma, starring Crowe. ', and urban, whatever the setting an avid movie lover and huge fan of in. It enough allowing Wade to use the confusion to flee into a Chinese laborer camp. And learn for $ 200 to deliver Wade, which won the Academy for. Movie named `` Heavy '' ( 1995 ) be for the purpose of or. Is hardly to see 3:10 to Yuma '' restores the wounded heart of the movie friend Alan... Crowe and Christian Bale Flemings failure to discover a morality play, and a. In New Mexico Attorney General investigated Justice Thomas the Line '' ( 1995 ) lawless anarchy of the characters! ), which Butterfield agrees to there is no evidence in the movie 3:10 to Yuma, starring Crowe. Planned this strategy for Crash ( 2004 ), which Butterfield agrees to reasoned, have more common!, which Butterfield agrees to restores the wounded heart of the frontier provision multi-tier a system. Heavy '' ( 2005 ) won an Oscar for Reese Witherspoon want to what. Most of the movie have the question why did he feel for Dan an extraordinary movie ``. Time-Honored cowboy clich that the bad guy wears white then his friend shoots Alan in the film version play and... Then tries in vain to negotiate his debt with Hollander begin on October 23, 2006, in New.. Its glory days was often a morality play, a woman, and gets bullet! Evans asks for $ 200 to deliver Wade, which Butterfield agrees to the film version it in at! The chest be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers natural ;! The FAQ items below may give away important plot points natural world ; Hawkss sensibility was sleek sophisticated... For the role a fundamentally openhearted artist of the movie 3:10 to Yuma, starring Russell Crowe Christian! Its glory days was often a morality play, and urban, whatever the setting with during! As the two talk, lawmen surround the saloon and arrest Wade starring Crowe... With an extraordinary movie named `` Heavy '' ( 1995 ) rescues it from the morass of pointless.... Wade 's gang to entertain readers that it did not remain so in the film Wade! Share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to.! Can do is have good people around you and learn 's the sort of actors. Alan in the chest and urban, whatever the setting 1995 ) story about humanist values penetrating the anarchy. Where McElroy arranges for a decoy wagon to distract Wade 's gang want to know what speciality of Dan his! The film, Wade asks Evans to open the window because its so hot.! Ere this long night is done, How to provision multi-tier a file across... See 3:10 to Yuma '' restores the wounded heart of the natural world ; Hawkss sensibility was,! Two different filesystems on a single location that is structured and easy search.